We must stop viewing police from a top-down law-enforcement perspective but instead as part of a solution to social problems.
Yvonne Sam
On November 1, when I heard the news on the radio that a male had been pepper sprayed at close range by the Montreal police ( SPVM), that he was experiencing a mental crisis, and had been taken to the hospital, the only words that evoked an egress from my lips were “ Not again!”
Surprisingly, not for a nanosecond did an inkling of a thought linger on the color aspect, as I intuitively knew the color that most often gets in trouble with law enforcement.
In 2019, in the face of harsh criticism for its handling of past interactions, the SPVM declared that it will train all its patrol officers to use tools that will help them deal with those suffering from mental health issues.
The patrollers would complete a one-day course within the next three years focusing on how to de-escalate situations involving “vulnerable” individuals. The duration of the training raised some common concerns, and criticism for not being too comprehensive.
It is clearly obvious that while the police may have received training, there has been no outward sign of “gaining.”
In August 2021, amidst calls for reform, the Montreal police, social intervention workers set up a trial response team to respond to calls about people in psychological distress in public spaces downtown.
Beginning September 1, 2021 Équipe mobile de médiation et d’intervention sociale (ÉMMIS), was due to put into place initiatives to de-escalate crises in public spaces and direct vulnerable people to the appropriate resources.
The service would be available seven days a week 9 AM to midnight and run until the end of the year.
The city’s ultimate goal is to make ÉMMIS a 24/7 service across the island. According to newly-re-elected Mayor Valerie LaPlante the pilot project is the first of its kind in Quebec.
However, it is imperative that these mobile crisis teams be staffed with crisis-trained behavioral health clinicians, who are culturally aware of systemic bias and racism, and can respond quickly, assess, deescalate, treat and assist in transporting the individual in crisis to the correct level of care, instead of involving the police.
Asking police to respond to acute mental health crises is grossly inappropriate on a number of counts. Firstly they are not clinicians, and asking them to make a clinical assessment, or intervene with a person who is experiencing emotional distress is totally unreasonable.
In fact, it can be detrimental to both the individual in need of help and potentially to the police themselves. It must always be kept foremost that the police force is not a health service, it is a force.
Now making health-only teams the default response will strikingly reduce the number of times that the police respond, thereby ensuring that people get the physical and mental health care they need quickly.
All over the world people live with mental illness without being shot and killed by police. In large part, the reason for such a state of affairs is because police in many countries are not trained with the “shoot first, ask questions later” mentality.
In most European countries, in terms of addressing social issues policing is seen as a small part of a bigger set of actors. It is not a case of : “there is a problem, send the police;” instead it is a case of: “there’s a problem let’s work together towards a solution.”
As a matter of fact, in many countries it is the standard for mental health experts and nurses to travel along with, or instead of —-police into situations involving mental health emergencies.
Neither the mental health system nor the law enforcement system can manage mental health crises in the community without help from each other.
However, if the collaboration between the two systems is to be successful, both the police and mental health professionals need to remember who they are. It is of equal importance that police officers be aware that their primary role remains that of law enforcement, even though they may have specialized mental health training.
There are no simple solutions to this crisis, the bottom line however is that what we have ready to put into action is feasible.
On the first day of Black History Month 2026, I had the privilege of addressing the congregation at the Unitarian Church of Montreal—Canada’s first Unitarian
Get the latest community news delivered to your inbox.
Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
We must stop viewing police from a top-down law-enforcement perspective but instead as part of a solution to social problems.
Yvonne Sam
Surprisingly, not for a nanosecond did an inkling of a thought linger on the color aspect, as I intuitively knew the color that most often gets in trouble with law enforcement.
In 2019, in the face of harsh criticism for its handling of past interactions, the SPVM declared that it will train all its patrol officers to use tools that will help them deal with those suffering from mental health issues.
The patrollers would complete a one-day course within the next three years focusing on how to de-escalate situations involving “vulnerable” individuals. The duration of the training raised some common concerns, and criticism for not being too comprehensive.
It is clearly obvious that while the police may have received training, there has been no outward sign of “gaining.”
In August 2021, amidst calls for reform, the Montreal police, social intervention workers set up a trial response team to respond to calls about people in psychological distress in public spaces downtown.
Beginning September 1, 2021 Équipe mobile de médiation et d’intervention sociale (ÉMMIS), was due to put into place initiatives to de-escalate crises in public spaces and direct vulnerable people to the appropriate resources.
The service would be available seven days a week 9 AM to midnight and run until the end of the year.
The city’s ultimate goal is to make ÉMMIS a 24/7 service across the island. According to newly-re-elected Mayor Valerie LaPlante the pilot project is the first of its kind in Quebec.
However, it is imperative that these mobile crisis teams be staffed with crisis-trained behavioral health clinicians, who are culturally aware of systemic bias and racism, and can respond quickly, assess, deescalate, treat and assist in transporting the individual in crisis to the correct level of care, instead of involving the police.
Asking police to respond to acute mental health crises is grossly inappropriate on a number of counts. Firstly they are not clinicians, and asking them to make a clinical assessment, or intervene with a person who is experiencing emotional distress is totally unreasonable.
In fact, it can be detrimental to both the individual in need of help and potentially to the police themselves. It must always be kept foremost that the police force is not a health service, it is a force.
Now making health-only teams the default response will strikingly reduce the number of times that the police respond, thereby ensuring that people get the physical and mental health care they need quickly.
All over the world people live with mental illness without being shot and killed by police. In large part, the reason for such a state of affairs is because police in many countries are not trained with the “shoot first, ask questions later” mentality.
In most European countries, in terms of addressing social issues policing is seen as a small part of a bigger set of actors. It is not a case of : “there is a problem, send the police;” instead it is a case of: “there’s a problem let’s work together towards a solution.”
As a matter of fact, in many countries it is the standard for mental health experts and nurses to travel along with, or instead of —-police into situations involving mental health emergencies.
Neither the mental health system nor the law enforcement system can manage mental health crises in the community without help from each other.
However, if the collaboration between the two systems is to be successful, both the police and mental health professionals need to remember who they are. It is of equal importance that police officers be aware that their primary role remains that of law enforcement, even though they may have specialized mental health training.
There are no simple solutions to this crisis, the bottom line however is that what we have ready to put into action is feasible.
Aleuta The struggle continues.
Yvonne Sam
Related Articles
I WONDER, AS I WANDER
On the first day of Black History Month 2026, I had the privilege of addressing the congregation at the Unitarian Church of Montreal—Canada’s first Unitarian
Tabanca: When the Spirit Tells the Body Where It Belongs
Salutations Everyone! I hope you all are excited, because we can see evidence that spring is coming! If you did not read my last article,
Categories
Events
Church & Gospel
News
Current Issue
Sports
Obituaries
Community News
Caribbean News
African News
Entertainment
Opinions
Special Features
Trending Now
01
Montreal CEGEP students rally for paid placements and better financial aid
01
A SECOND CHANCE
01
WELCOME TO ISLAND CURRY HOUSE!
01
Study seeks Black families’ experiences in vocational education
01
Noël Gospel celebrates the season as Jireh Gospel Choir marks 30 years
Advertise With Us
Reach Montreal's Black and Caribbean communities. Partner with a trusted voice.
Subscribe
Get the latest community news delivered to your inbox.